Old-Fashioned Food
Old-Fashioned Food in Mayville, Wisconsin, has a real cheese cellar that draws you in the moment you step inside. They keep a raw honey lineup that actually tastes like the countryside, pairing it with jams, sausages, and pantry staples that make a simple shopping trip feel like a local tasting. The cheese cellar is a standout, you can browse ready-cut wedges or have something weighed to size, neatly wrapped for a road trip or picnic. Beyond honey, there’s a steady stream of local cheeses, plus wines and preserves that turn a quick stop into a small feast. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, patient with questions and quick to steer you toward a good match. Even through renovations, the small-town vibe stays intact, a reminder that Mayville’s best finds are still here. When you’re nearby, swing by Old-Fashioned Food for a jar of honey and a little taste of Wisconsin life.