Local Honey Map
Local Honey Map Find Local Honey Near You
Local Honey Seller 4.6 (11)

Mitchell's Honey Company

Local Honey Seller in New Paris, Indiana · Raw Honey

Mitchell's Honey Company

Mitchell's Honey Company in New Paris, Indiana, is the kind of small operation you tell friends about over coffee. The honey here tastes fresh and bright, with a flavor that locals swear is a notch above the rest and a price that feels fair for the quality. Reviewers consistently describe the owner as honest and knowledgeable, always up for answering a question and sharing bee lore. Loyal customers keep coming back because the honey is proudly local to New Paris and reliably good. There aren’t a ton of bells and whistles, just solid, high quality honey from a beekeeper who treats the bees right. If you want to bring a jar home, the easiest move is to swing by the source in New Paris, Indiana and grab what you need. Mitchell's Honey Company leaves you with a memory of a warm, friendly encounter and a jar that makes toast taste like summer all year long. A standout local pick in Indiana.

Reviews

What Customers Say

One of the best ways to evaluate a local honey producer is through the experiences of people who have already bought from them. Customer reviews reveal details that a product listing never will: how the honey tastes compared to store-bought, whether the beekeeper is friendly and knowledgeable, and whether people come back for more.

  • Customers consistently praise the flavor of Mitchell's honey and note good value and a solid local selection.
  • Reviewers describe the owner as honest, knowledgeable, and willing to answer questions.
  • Regular customers express loyalty, highlighting that the honey is local to New Paris and frequently return to purchase more.
  • Overall sentiment from reviews is that the honey is high quality and well-regarded in the local area.
About the Seller

About This Seller

Not every place that sells honey is the same. A backyard beekeeper managing a handful of hives produces a very different product than a grocery store stocking mass-market brands. Knowing the seller type helps you understand how close you are to the source. The closer you are, the fresher and more traceable the honey.

Local Honey Seller

We don't have confirmed details on what type of seller Mitchell's Honey Company is. They may be a beekeeper, a farm, or a retail shop. If this matters to you, reaching out to them directly is the best way to find out.

22468 Co Rd 50, New Paris, IN 46553, United States

+1 574-326-9152
www.mitchellshoneycompany.com
View on Google Maps
Processing

Raw & Unfiltered Status

How honey is processed after harvest makes a significant difference in what ends up in the jar. Raw honey preserves the enzymes, pollen, and antioxidants that heat destroys. Unfiltered honey retains the fine particles of beeswax, propolis, and pollen that commercial filtering removes. Crystallization is actually a sign of raw, minimally processed honey, not a flaw.

We don't have confirmed information about whether Mitchell's Honey Company sells raw or filtered honey. If the processing method matters to you, it's worth asking the seller directly. Most beekeepers and honey producers are happy to explain how they handle their harvest.

Varietals

Honey Varietals

Honey takes on the flavor, color, and aroma of whatever flowers the bees are foraging. A jar of pale, mild clover honey tastes nothing like dark, earthy buckwheat, even if both come from hives in the same county. Seasonal and regional variation is part of what makes local honey worth seeking out. No two batches are exactly alike.

Specific honey varietals for Mitchell's Honey Company haven't been confirmed. Many local sellers in Indiana offer wildflower blends that reflect the seasonal bloom in their area. Contacting the seller is the best way to find out what's currently available.

Health

Local Honey & Allergies

One of the most common reasons people seek out local honey is the belief that it can help with seasonal allergies. Bees collect pollen from nearby plants, trace amounts end up in the honey, and regularly eating that honey may help your body build tolerance over time. For those interested in trying it, raw and unfiltered honey is preferred, since commercial processing removes most pollen content.

No reviewers have mentioned purchasing Mitchell's Honey Company honey specifically for allergy reasons. That doesn't mean it wouldn't be suitable. If local pollen content matters to you, ask the seller about where their hives are located and how their honey is processed.

Visit

Can You Visit?

There's something about visiting a local honey producer in person that no online listing can replicate. Seeing the hives, meeting the beekeeper, tasting different varietals side by side - it gives you a connection to the product that a grocery shelf never will. Many farms and apiaries welcome visitors, offer tastings, and sell directly on-site, often at better prices than retail.

Not confirmed

We don't have confirmed information about whether you can visit Mitchell's Honey Company in person. If a farm visit or on-site purchase in New Paris, Indiana is important to you, reaching out to the seller directly before making the trip is recommended.

Purchasing

Where to Buy

Finding where to actually purchase local honey can be the hardest part of the process. Many producers sell through limited channels like weekend farmers markets, seasonal farm stands, or small online shops that may sell out between harvests. Direct purchases from the beekeeper, whether at a market, farm stand, or their own website, typically offer the freshest product.

We don't have confirmed sales channel information for Mitchell's Honey Company. To find out how to purchase their honey in New Paris, Indiana, we recommend contacting them directly or checking their website for the most current availability.

Products

Products Available

A jar of liquid honey is just the starting point for many local producers. Beekeepers often offer a full range of hive-derived products: comb honey, creamed honey, infused varieties, beeswax candles, skincare products, pollen, and propolis. A diverse product range usually signals a knowledgeable, established operation.

We don't have confirmed details on the full product range at Mitchell's Honey Company beyond honey. Many local producers in Indiana carry additional hive products. It's worth asking about comb honey, beeswax items, or other specialties when you make contact.

Hours

Opening Hours

  • Monday 8 am-6 pm
  • Tuesday 8 am-6 pm
  • Wednesday 8 am-6 pm
  • Thursday 8 am-6 pm
  • Friday 8 am-6 pm
  • Saturday 8 am-6 pm
  • Sunday Closed
FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Mitchell's Honey Company sell raw or unfiltered honey?
We don't have confirmed information about whether Mitchell's Honey Company sells raw or unfiltered honey. Many local producers in Indiana do offer raw and unfiltered options, but processing methods vary. If this matters to you, contacting Mitchell's Honey Company in New Paris directly is the best way to find out how they handle their harvest.
What types of honey does Mitchell's Honey Company offer?
Specific honey varietals for Mitchell's Honey Company haven't been confirmed. Local honey in Indiana commonly includes varieties like wildflower, clover, and other region-specific blooms, but what's available depends on the season and location of the hives. Contacting Mitchell's Honey Company in New Paris is the best way to find out what they currently have.
How can I buy honey from Mitchell's Honey Company in New Paris, Indiana?
We don't have confirmed details on where to buy honey from Mitchell's Honey Company. Local honey sellers in New Paris, Indiana commonly sell through farmers markets, farm stands, or their own websites, but availability varies. Contacting Mitchell's Honey Company directly or checking their website and social media is the best way to find current purchasing options.
How should I store honey from Mitchell's Honey Company?
Honey from Mitchell's Honey Company should be stored at room temperature in a sealed container away from direct sunlight. There's no need to refrigerate it; in fact, refrigeration accelerates crystallization. If your honey does crystallize over time, that's completely normal and a sign of natural, minimally processed honey. To return it to liquid form, place the jar in a warm water bath (not boiling) and stir gently. Avoid microwaving, as high heat can damage the enzymes and beneficial compounds, especially in raw honey. Properly stored, honey has an essentially indefinite shelf life.
How do I know if honey from Mitchell's Honey Company is real honey?
Buying from a local producer like Mitchell's Honey Company in New Paris, Indiana is one of the most reliable ways to ensure you're getting real honey. Imported and mass-market honey is frequently adulterated with sugar syrups or ultra-filtered to remove pollen, making it impossible to trace the origin. Local honey from a known source avoids these issues entirely. Signs of authentic, minimally processed honey include natural crystallization over time, slight variations in color and flavor between batches, and a thicker texture than commercial brands. If you want to know more about how Mitchell's Honey Company harvests and processes their honey, most local producers are happy to explain.
Discover More

More Honey Sellers in New Paris & Indiana

Spangler Farms Market
Farmers' market
Farmers Market · Visitable

Spangler Farms Market

In Yorktown, Indiana, Spangler Farms Market greets you with a bright mix of sunflowers and honey at the farm stand. It’s more than a stand; it’s a small village market where local honey carries the warm, floral notes from nearby fields, sitting shoulder to shoulder with seasonal produce, fresh flowers, crafts, and kid-friendly pumpkins come fall. Shoppers in Yorktown love the vibe, a friendly, family-friendly spot that makes you feel you're buying from neighbors who know their land. The honey is clearly local, part of a steady stream of goods that locals return for, year after year, and the produce is consistently flavorful. You can shop here at the farm stand or at the farmers market, taking home a jar of honey and a basket of corn or mums. It’s the kind of place that sticks in your memory, where the people behind the counters greet you with a smile and you leave feeling you’ve supported your own community.

View listing
Herbs & Heirlooms Inc
Metaphysical supply store
Store

Herbs & Heirlooms Inc

Terre Haute, Indiana has a sweet spot where local honey slips into a larger story of teas, herbs, and oils. Herbs & Heirlooms is that shop: a 25-year-old mainstay that feels like a warm, well-loved pantry for the Wabash Valley. The honey is real local stuff, tucked among crystals, candles, and countless natural remedies, a reminder that this isn’t just a general store but a neighborhood hub for folks who care about what they put in their cups and on their skin. You’ll also find a generous run of herbal teas, essential oils, and handmade goods that make a longer shopping list feel like a treasure hunt. In Terre Haute you can stop in and pick up honey, tea, and remedies in person at the retail store, with staff who know their inventory and their Indiana herbs. Loyal customers keep coming back year after year, which is the best compliment a shop can get. Here in Terre Haute, this shop remains a community anchor.

View listing
McComBees Apiaries
Honey farm
Beekeeper

McComBees Apiaries

At McComBees Apiaries in Yoder, Indiana, the first thing you notice is the aroma of cinnamon drifting from their Cinnamon Creamed Honey, a flavor profile shoppers call the best they've ever had. They keep it real with raw honey, plus creamed honey that spreads like velvet and a honey stick option for on-the-go taste. Beyond honey, they offer comb honey, pollen, beeswax candles, and a few thoughtful extras all produced from their small on-site apiary. They sell through an easy online store and a long list of Indiana farmers markets, including Fort Wayne and Purdue campus markets, so you can chase a sample or a full jar in person. The beekeepers are friendly and patient, ready to answer questions and share what makes their bees tick. Orders ship quickly and packaging is careful, which matters when you’re shipping fragile honey gifts to friends or family. In Yoder and across Indiana, McComBees Apiaries is a local honey source you can rely on for flavor that loves to linger.

View listing
Indy Winter Farmers Market
Farmers' market
Farmers Market · Visitable

Indy Winter Farmers Market

A weekend find at the Indy Winter Farmers Market in Indianapolis, Indiana, the honey stall feels like a neighborhood treasure, connecting you to area beekeepers and the winter buzz of the city. Local honey from area beekeepers is the star here, jars carrying the memory of fields and patient, careful work. The honey you taste is pure, approachable, and built for pairing with crusty bread, sharp dairy, or a bright morning coffee. The stall sits among a diverse mix of vendors, so you can wander with a sample and walk away with honey plus produce or pastries. It’s easy to shop in person during the market, with many vendors accepting cards and others using token-like Growing Places credits if needed. The Indy Winter Farmers Market is a community hub in Indianapolis, Indiana that makes friendly conversation with beekeepers part of the experience. It’s a welcoming, repeatable weekend stop you’ll crave.

View listing
Bittner Apiaries, Inc. DBA as PJB Honey
Farm
Farm & Apiary

Bittner Apiaries, Inc. DBA as PJB Honey

In Haubstadt, Indiana, PJB Honey from Bittner Apiaries is a family-run operation that bottles honey straight from their own hives with real care. The result is honey that many buyers say is among the best they’ve ever tasted, a clean, just-right sweetness with character that lingers. The bottling is diligent, a quiet pride that shines in every jar. Beyond honey, not much else is on offer from this small farm, but what they do, they do well. You can find PJB Honey at local Schnucks stores around the region, or swing by the Haubstadt farm for a direct purchase. Loyal customers keep coming back for that dependable, consistent flavor that tastes like a day at the hive. If you’re chasing a truly local jar with a story behind it, PJB Honey delivers, a favorite for local pantries and for anyone visiting Haubstadt.

View listing
Circle Q Acres Farm Market
Farmers' market
Farmers Market · Visitable

Circle Q Acres Farm Market

Visit Circle Q Acres Farm Market in Wolcottville, Indiana, and you’ll notice local honey front and center at the Wolcottville farmers market, twinned with maple syrup and jams. This family-run spot is where the kitchen table meets the market table, the Circle Q kids pitch in, and Hazel the staffer is as helpful as a neighbor showing you the best sweetness for your baking. The honey is your go-to for baking and for simple, everyday remedies, a reminder that a jar can do double duty in pantry and medicine cabinet. Beyond honey, you’ll find a small but thoughtful lineup of maple syrup and jams, all anchored in local farming. You can shop in person at the Wolcottville market each weekend, and if you want updates, their Facebook page is a good bet. Circle Q Acres feels like a seat at a friendly, busy kitchen table, trustworthy, local, and proudly Indiana.

View listing